After countless trips exploring every corner of this stunning Bahamian island, I’ve learned that where you stay in Eleuthera can make or break your vacation.
Picture this: a 110-mile-long island only a mile wide, blessed with pink sand beaches that you’ll often have entirely to yourself. Amazing, right?
But here’s the thing—choosing the right location in this long, skinny paradise is essential. I made the mistake of booking a beautiful rental only to realize it was an hour’s drive from the restaurants and activities I wanted to experience! Let me save you from making the same mistakes I did.
In this guide, I’ll walk you through everything you need to know about where to stay in Eleuthera for 2024, from the stunning shores of North Eleuthera to the peaceful beaches of the South. Trust me, after helping dozens of friends plan their perfect Eleuthera getaway, I know exactly what questions you need answered!
Best Overall Places to Stay in Eleuthera
Let’s start with what you’re really here for – the absolute best places to stay on the island. Having personally visited or stayed at most properties on Eleuthera, I can tell you that one stands out above the rest.
Cayo Loco: The Crown Jewel
I’ll never forget the first time I drove up to Cayo Loco. The property literally took my breath away! Perched on a hillside overlooking both the Caribbean and Atlantic oceans, this stunning vacation rental offers something truly unique in Eleuthera – panoramic water views from almost every room.
What makes Cayo Loco special:
- Unmatched location with dual ocean views
- Private beach access to pristine pink sand
- Spacious rooms that comfortably sleep 8
- Modern amenities while maintaining island charm
- Central location perfect for exploring
Price range: $$$$ (but worth every penny for special occasions or family gatherings)
Other Top Properties Worth Considering
While Cayo Loco holds the top spot, there are several other exceptional properties I frequently recommend:
French Leave Resort This Autograph Collection gem brings luxury to Governor’s Harbour. The beach here is absolutely stunning – I’ve spent entire afternoons just walking along the pink sand! Perfect for couples wanting high-end amenities.
The Cove Eleuthera A boutique resort that perfectly balances luxury with laid-back island vibes. Their infinity pool overlooking the ocean is Instagram-famous for good reason! Best for romantic getaways.
La Bougainvillea A charming small hotel that won’t break the bank. The owner makes you feel like family – she even helped me arrange a last-minute fishing trip once!
Pineapple Fields Resort These condo-style units are my go-to recommendation for families. Having a full kitchen and spacious living area makes such a difference for longer stays.
North Eleuthera Area Guide
The northern part of Eleuthera has its own special charm. It’s more developed than the south but still maintains that authentic Bahamian feel I’ve grown to love.
Spanish Wells
Spanish Wells deserves special attention – it’s technically its own island but connected to Eleuthera by bridge. This fishing village offers a completely different vibe from the rest of Eleuthera.
What I love about staying here:
- Safe, walkable community
- Amazing seafood (freshest lobster I’ve ever had!)
- Beautiful protected beaches
- Easy golf cart access to everything
The downside? You’ll need to take a water taxi to access mainland Eleuthera’s attractions. But for a peaceful, authentic experience, it might be worth it.
Harbour Island Connection
While Harbour Island (or ‘Briland’ as locals call it) is its own destination, it’s worth mentioning because many visitors combine it with an Eleuthera stay. The ferry from North Eleuthera takes just 10 minutes.
I usually recommend spending a few days on each island rather than trying to do day trips. The water taxi schedule can be unpredictable, and you’ll want time to soak in each island’s unique atmosphere.
Central Eleuthera: Governor’s Harbour Area
After years of exploring Eleuthera, I’ve concluded that Governor’s Harbour offers the perfect home base for most visitors. Here’s why I love it:
Advantages of staying in Governor’s Harbour:
- Central location cuts down on driving time
- Close to GHB airport
- Best restaurant selection on the island
- Friday night Fish Fry (a must-do!)
- Beautiful beaches on both sides of the island
The accommodations here range from luxury to budget-friendly. I’ve found that vacation rentals often offer the best value, especially for stays longer than a few days.
South Eleuthera Accommodations
The southern part of Eleuthera holds a special place in my heart. It’s where I first discovered the real, untouched Bahamas, away from the tourist crowds. Let me tell you about the two main areas you’ll want to consider.
Rock Sound Area
Rock Sound might not have the name recognition of Governor’s Harbour, but that’s part of its charm. I stumbled upon this gem during my second trip to Eleuthera, and it’s been a favorite ever since.
What makes Rock Sound special:
- Ocean Hole (an incredible natural wonder!)
- Local grocery store with good supplies
- Quieter, more authentic experience
- Lower accommodation prices
- Easy access to South Eleuthera airport
Best properties in Rock Sound:
- Wild Orchid: Comfortable rooms with amazing ocean views
- Rock Sound Club: Historic property with loads of character
- Vacation rentals starting around $200/night
Pro tip: I’ve found the best deals on accommodations here during shoulder season (October-November). Just keep an eye on the weather reports!
Cape Eleuthera
At the island’s southern tip, Cape Eleuthera offers a completely different experience. It’s more remote, but that’s exactly why some visitors fall in love with it.
Cape Eleuthera highlights:
- World-class fishing opportunities
- Private marina access
- Pristine, untouched beaches
- Perfect for nature lovers
- Great for boat owners
Who it’s best for:
- Fishing enthusiasts
- Privacy seekers
- Adventure travelers
- Boaters
- Nature photographers
Tips for Choosing Your Location
After helping countless friends plan their Eleuthera trips, I’ve developed a foolproof system for choosing the right location. Here’s what you need to consider:
Transportation Considerations
Let me be straight with you – you WILL need a car in Eleuthera. I learned this the hard way during my first visit! Here’s what to think about:
- Airport proximity: Which airport will you fly into? North Eleuthera (ELH), Governor’s Harbour (GHB), or Rock Sound (RSD)?
- Rental car availability: Book in advance! I once had to wait two days for an available car
- Road conditions: Some areas have rougher roads than others
- Distance to attractions: How far are you willing to drive daily?
Activity Access
I always tell friends to list their must-do activities before choosing accommodation. Here’s why:
Beach access:
- Caribbean side: Calmer waters, perfect for families
- Atlantic side: Better for surfers and snorkelers
- Some properties offer access to both!
Restaurant proximity:
- Governor’s Harbour has the most options
- Spanish Wells is great for seafood
- Southern settlements have fewer choices but more authentic experiences
Popular attractions:
- Glass Window Bridge (North)
- Lighthouse Beach (South)
- Queen’s Bath (North-Central)
- Ocean Hole (South)
Seasonal Considerations
When to visit can be just as important as where to stay. Here’s what I’ve learned over multiple visits:
High Season (December-April):
- Perfect weather
- Higher prices
- Need to book well in advance
- More activities available
Low Season (June-November):
- Better deals
- Fewer crowds
- Some restaurants may have limited hours
- Hurricane risk (get travel insurance!)
Budget Considerations & Booking Tips
Let’s talk money – because Eleuthera can be as budget-friendly or as luxurious as you make it.
Price ranges by area:
- Luxury: $500-1000+/night
- Mid-range: $200-500/night
- Budget guesthouses: $100-200/night
- Vacation rentals: Wide range, usually better value for longer stays
Money-saving tips I’ve learned:
- Book directly with property owners when possible
- Visit during shoulder season (May or November)
- Stay longer – many places offer weekly discounts
- Consider properties slightly off the beach
- Split a larger house with family or friends
After exploring every nook and cranny of this unique island, I can tell you that where you stay in Eleuthera truly shapes your experience. If you’re looking for the perfect balance of comfort, location, and value, you can’t go wrong with Cayo Loco or one of the properties in Governor’s Harbour. For a more secluded experience, head south to Rock Sound or Cape Eleuthera. And if you want that perfect Instagram-worthy luxury stay, French Leave Resort or The Cove won’t disappoint.
Remember, Eleuthera isn’t your typical tourist destination – and that’s exactly what makes it special. Whether you choose a luxury resort or a simple beach cottage, you’re in for an authentic Bahamian experience you won’t find anywhere else.
Ready to book your Eleuthera adventure?
Don’t forget to check my other guides about restaurants, activities, and transportation on the island.